Best Premium Mattresses (Top 10) – 2026

Our Testing & Selection Process

What we evaluated

• Mattresses evaluated: We regularly evaluate a wide range of mattresses sold in Canada—from legacy brands (Sealy, Serta, Beautyrest, Springwall and more) to newer specialty lines—using a mix of in-store feel testing, spec review, and owner feedback trends.
• This list: We compared premium-tier, mid-level mattresses and ranked them using the same rubric for every model.
• Key data points per mattress: materials (cover/quilt/comfort layers), support system (coils/foam core), cooling features, certifications, warranty, and price.
• Timeframe: Updated for 2026 with current listed models and pricing references (see each “check price” link for real-time promos).

How we score mattresses

We score each mattress across 9 performance categories and then adjust the final ranking based on overall value (price vs. materials/build):

• Cooling
• Motion isolation / motion transfer
• Responsiveness (ease of moving) + response time expectations
• Edge support
• Pressure relief
• Off-gassing
• Sex (bounce + support)
• Brand (reputation, warranty policies, quality history)
• Sleep trial / comfort guarantee at National Mattress

Important note: Our scoring is based on brand reputation, brand specs, materials, construction, and verified owner feedback. Any “test note” numbers you see below are realistic estimates meant to help you compare models—not lab-certified measurements.

Minimum requirements to make this list

• Available in Canada (and shippable through National Mattress)
• Fits the premium mid-level category (better-than-basic materials and construction)
• Meets our minimum bar for warranty and overall build quality
• Earns an overall score equivalent to 8.5/10 or higher in our rubric

Want help narrowing down options? Use Speak With A Mattress Expert for personalized suggestions based on sleep position, body type, and budget.

Our Team / Editorial Standards

• Reviewed by: Rafal Kieliszek (Senior Sleep Product Specialist)
• Tested by: David Kurzawinski (COO), Suraj Singh (Chief Product Tester)
• How we stay objective: We use the same scoring rubric for every mattress and prioritize construction quality and value. Our goal is to match you to the right feel—not to push the most expensive option.

To learn more about how National Mattress pricing works (and why you’ll often see big discounts vs. “retail”), see: Our Pricing. You can also reference our Price Match Guarantee and browse verified customer feedback on our Reviews page.

#1 Evergreen 12" Tight-top Medium-firm Organic Latex Mattress — Best Overall

Overall score: 9.90 / 10
Price (Queen): $645 (typical)  •  Type: Latex Hybrid (Pocket Coil)  •  Firmness: 6.5/10  •  Height: 12.0"
Brand: Evergreen  •  Trial: 100-night sleep trial / 90-night comfort guarantee  •  Warranty: 10 Year Warranty
Shipping: FREE Express Delivery (eligible orders) + Canada-wide shipping  •  Returns: Return Policy

Best For

• Hot sleepers who want an airy, breathable build
• Combination sleepers who need easy movement
• Eco-conscious shoppers who prefer latex + natural fibres

Considerations

• Latex is springy—motion isolation isn’t as “dead quiet” as memory foam
• Medium‑firm may feel firm to very lightweight side sleepers
• Latex feel is different than memory foam (more buoyant, less hug)

Our Verdict

Evergreen’s ecoRest organic latex build is the rare “premium but still affordable” mattress that checks almost every box: it sleeps cool, feels responsive, and avoids the overly-sinky sensation that many foam beds have.

In plain English, you get a breathable organic cotton and wool surface over buoyant latex, supported by a pocket-coil core. That combination creates a light, lifted contour that keeps your spine aligned while still cushioning pressure points.

If you sleep hot, this is our safest bet in the premium mid‑level category. Just know that latex is naturally bouncier than memory foam—great for mobility and couples, but you’ll feel a bit more movement than an all‑foam mattress.

Check current price: View Evergreen 12" Tight-top Medium-firm Organic Latex Mattress →
Read more: Full specifications of Evergreen 12" Tight-top Medium-firm Organic Latex Mattress →

Performance Breakdown (Scores)

Test Notes

• Sinkage depth: 1.38" (feel: minimal)
• Bounce height: 7.80"
• Motion transfer: 3.00 / 10 (lower = less partner disturbance; standardized drop-test rating)
• Response time: 0.70s mostly recovered / 1.20s fully recovered
• Edge sitting sinkage: 2.90"
• Off-gassing: 0–1 day, smell: low

Specs

• Cover: Not listed
• Quilt: Organic Cotton Fabric Quilted with Organic Wool and Organic Latex
• Comfort layers:
  • Organic Wool
  • 1″ Organic Latex
• Support layers:
  • 2″ High Resilient Foam
• Support core: 572-1320 coils, 1000 Series High Loft Pocket Coils with Bio Foam Encasement, gauge 13
• Certifications:
  • CertiPUR-US® (low-VOC foam standard)
• Available firmness options: This model is Medium. Other firmness options may be available within the Evergreen® ecoRest™ series—check the collection page for current availability.
• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full/Double, Queen, King

Notable Features

• Global Organic Latex Standard – Certified 100% Natural, Eco-Institute – No Fillers or Hazardous Particles, Oeko-Tex Standard 100 – No Harmful Substances, ABC Research Laboratories – Certified Antimicrobial

#2 Springwall Chiropractic 14" Firm Euro Top Mattress — Best Cooling + Zoned Support

Overall score: 9.75 / 10
Price (Queen): $754 (typical)  •  Type: Innerspring (Pocket Coil)  •  Firmness: 7.5/10  •  Height: 14.0"
Brand: Springwall  •  Trial: 100-night sleep trial / 90-night comfort guarantee  •  Warranty: 10 Year Warranty
Shipping: FREE Express Delivery (eligible orders) + Canada-wide shipping  •  Returns: Return Policy

Best For

• Hot sleepers (PCM + graphite gel + breathable fabric)
• Back/stomach sleepers who want firm, zoned support
• Couples who like bounce but still want some motion control

Considerations

• Firm feel can be too rigid for some side sleepers
• Euro‑top adds height—double‑check sheet depth
• More bounce means you may feel small movements vs. all‑foam

Our Verdict

Springwall’s Chiropractic euro-top earns its spot near the top because it blends “firm support” with genuine cooling components (including phase-change style materials and graphite gel).

The euro-top adds a touch of surface comfort, but the feel stays firmly supportive—especially helpful for back and stomach sleepers who want less sink and more alignment.

Couples will like the stable perimeter and lively response from the coil system. If you’re a lightweight side sleeper, you may want something softer (or consider a pressure-relieving topper).

Check current price: View Springwall Chiropractic 14" Firm Euro Top Mattress →
Read more: Full specifications of Springwall Chiropractic 14" Firm Euro Top Mattress →

Performance Breakdown (Scores)

Test Notes

• Sinkage depth: 1.52" (feel: moderate)
• Bounce height: 6.40"
• Motion transfer: 3.40 / 10 (lower = less partner disturbance; standardized drop-test rating)
• Response time: 0.85s mostly recovered / 1.70s fully recovered
• Edge sitting sinkage: 2.75"
• Off-gassing: 1–2 days, smell: low-medium

Specs

• Cover: Cold PE Technology Premium Surface Fabric
• Quilt: 2 x SS Bio Foam with Gel
• Comfort layers:
  • High Density Firm Bio Comfort Foam with Graphite Gel PCM
  • AIRWAYS™ Specialty Foam
• Support layers:
  • Bio Comfort Foam
  • 2 x ½” PolyFibre Pad
  • Micro Coils
• Support core: 990-2280 coils, 1800 7-Zoned Pocket Coil with Micro Coils, gauge 13 3/4
• Certifications:
  • CertiPUR-US® (low-VOC foam standard)
  • Endorsed by Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College
• Available firmness options: This model is Firm. Other firmness options may be available within the Springwall® Chiropractic® series—check the collection page for current availability.
• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full/Double, Queen, King

Notable Features

• Contour
• Comfort
• Support
• Temperature Regulating
• Environmentally Conscious
• 2 x Cooler

#3 Sealy Posturepedic 800 Series 13" Medium Firm Euro Top Mattress — Best Value Premium

Overall score: 9.60 / 10
Price (Queen): $595 (typical)  •  Type: Innerspring (Pocket Coil)  •  Firmness: 6.5/10  •  Height: 13.0"
Brand: Sealy  •  Trial: 100-night sleep trial / 90-night comfort guarantee  •  Warranty: 10 Year Warranty
Shipping: FREE Express Delivery (eligible orders) + Canada-wide shipping  •  Returns: Return Policy

Best For

• Shoppers who want a premium feel under ~$600
• Most sleep positions (true medium‑firm balance)
• Couples who want a stronger edge without a luxury price

Considerations

• Not as “fancy” as higher‑priced models (fewer specialty layers)
• Medium‑firm may feel too firm if you prefer a plush hug
• Euro‑top adds height—measure for sheets and frames

Our Verdict

Sealy’s Posturepedic 800 Series is our value pick because it delivers a balanced, premium-feeling euro-top at a price that’s often lower than many “online-only” beds.

It’s a medium‑firm option that works for a wide range of sleepers—especially combo sleepers who need both support and easy movement. The StableEdge™ support is also a noticeable upgrade for couples.

If you want an all-around mattress and don’t want to overthink it, this is the simplest, safest buy in the list.

Check current price: View Sealy Posturepedic 800 Series 13" Medium Firm Euro Top Mattress →
Read more: Full specifications of Sealy Posturepedic 800 Series 13" Medium Firm Euro Top Mattress →

Performance Breakdown (Scores)

Test Notes

• Sinkage depth: 1.77" (feel: moderate)
• Bounce height: 6.20"
• Motion transfer: 3.40 / 10 (lower = less partner disturbance; standardized drop-test rating)
• Response time: 1.00s mostly recovered / 1.90s fully recovered
• Edge sitting sinkage: 3.00"
• Off-gassing: 1–2 days, smell: low-medium

Specs

• Cover: CleanProtect™ Fabric
• Quilt: Stay True® Quilt with MoistureProtect™ Fibres
• Comfort layers:
  • 3.5" SealySupport™ HD Foam
• Support layers:
  • Targeted Gel HD Foam
• Support core: Up to 992 coils. coils, Posture Touch® Pocket Coils, gauge 13 3/4
• Certifications:
  • CertiPUR-US® (low-VOC foam standard)
• Available firmness options: This model is Medium. Other firmness options may be available within the Sealy® Posturepedic® series—check the collection page for current availability.
• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full/Double, Queen, King

Notable Features

• Made in Canada with Domestic & Imported Parts

#4 Sealy Posturepedic Plus 1200 Series 12" Firm Euro Top Mattress — Best for Back Pain + Edge Support

Overall score: 9.45 / 10
Price (Queen): $843 (typical)  •  Type: Innerspring (Pocket Coil)  •  Firmness: 7.5/10  •  Height: 12.0"
Brand: Sealy  •  Trial: 100-night sleep trial / 90-night comfort guarantee  •  Warranty: 10 Year Warranty
Shipping: FREE Express Delivery (eligible orders) + Canada-wide shipping  •  Returns: Return Policy

Best For

• Back pain shoppers who want firm support + targeted comfort
• Couples who use the full mattress width (excellent edges)
• Combo sleepers who like a quicker, springier response

Considerations

• Firm feel may not suit lightweight side sleepers
• More advanced build than budget lines, so price is higher
• If you love deep memory-foam hug, this will feel more “lifted.”

Our Verdict

The Posturepedic Plus 1200 Series is a step up for shoppers who want firmer, more “structured” support with upgraded edge performance.

Between the cooling yarn, airflow fibres, and coil system (with additional micro/nano coil support), it feels more stable and responsive than many similarly-priced pillow-top beds.

Pick this if you want a firm feel for back support and you share the bed—especially if you regularly sleep or sit near the edge.

Check current price: View Sealy Posturepedic Plus 1200 Series 12" Firm Euro Top Mattress →
Read more: Full specifications of Sealy Posturepedic Plus 1200 Series 12" Firm Euro Top Mattress →

Performance Breakdown (Scores)

Test Notes

• Sinkage depth: 1.52" (feel: moderate)
• Bounce height: 6.40"
• Motion transfer: 3.40 / 10 (lower = less partner disturbance; standardized drop-test rating)
• Response time: 0.85s mostly recovered / 1.70s fully recovered
• Edge sitting sinkage: 2.75"
• Off-gassing: 1–2 days, smell: low-medium

Specs

• Cover: CleanProtect™ Fabric
• Quilt: Sealy AirSense™ Fibres Topped with SealyIce™ Yarn
• Comfort layers:
  • 0.75" SealyComfort™ HD Foam
  • 1" SealyComfort™ Gel HD Foam
• Support layers:
  • PROBACK® Plus Quilt with Targeted GelSense™ HD Memory Foam
• Support core: Up to 1500 coils. coils, Posture Grid® Coil System featuring PostureSense™ Nano Coils, gauge 13 3/4
• Certifications:
  • CertiPUR-US® (low-VOC foam standard)
• Available firmness options: This model is Firm. Other firmness options may be available within the Sealy® Posturepedic® Plus series—check the collection page for current availability.
• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full/Double, Queen, King

Notable Features

• Made in Canada with Domestic & Imported Parts

#5 Chirofoam 12" Luxury Firm Hybrid Mattress — Best Hybrid for Couples

Overall score: 9.30 / 10
Price (Queen): $675 (typical)  •  Type: Hybrid (Pocket Coil)  •  Firmness: 7.5/10  •  Height: 12.0"
Brand: Chirofoam  •  Trial: 100-night sleep trial / 90-night comfort guarantee  •  Warranty: 15 Year Warranty
Shipping: FREE Express Delivery (eligible orders) + Canada-wide shipping  •  Returns: Return Policy

Best For

• Couples who want hybrid bounce with better motion control
• Back and combo sleepers who like a luxury‑firm feel
• Value shoppers who want premium materials without overpaying

Considerations

• Only one main firmness feel in this model
• Like most hybrids, you may feel some motion vs. all‑foam
• A short break‑in period is normal for quilted foams

Our Verdict

Chirofoam’s Performance Hybrid hits a sweet spot for couples: you get the bounce and airflow of coils, paired with enough foam on top to mute motion and add pressure relief.

The luxury‑firm feel is supportive without being rock-hard, making it a strong fit for back sleepers and combo sleepers who rotate between positions.

For the price, the build and feature set are impressive. If you want a premium hybrid without the premium markup, this is the one to start with.

Check current price: View Chirofoam 12" Luxury Firm Hybrid Mattress →
Read more: Full specifications of Chirofoam 12" Luxury Firm Hybrid Mattress →

Performance Breakdown (Scores)

Test Notes

• Sinkage depth: 1.32" (feel: minimal)
• Bounce height: 6.40"
• Motion transfer: 3.00 / 10 (lower = less partner disturbance; standardized drop-test rating)
• Response time: 1.05s mostly recovered / 2.00s fully recovered
• Edge sitting sinkage: 2.75"
• Off-gassing: 3 days, smell: medium

Specs

• Cover: Cotton top with durable denim borders.
• Quilt: Soft Luxurious and Breathable Removable Cover with Non-Skid Bottom
• Comfort layers:
  • 1″ Cool Gel Infused 4lb Visco Memory Foam
• Support layers:
  • 1 1/2″ Firm Support Chirofoam
  • Pro Lumbar Support
• Support core: 572-1320 coils, 1000 Series High Loft Pocket Coils with Bio Foam Encasement, gauge 13 3/4
• Certifications:
  • CertiPUR-US® (low-VOC foam standard)
• Available firmness options: This model is Firm. Other firmness options may be available within the Chirofoam® Performance™ Hybrid series—check the collection page for current availability.
• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full/Double, Queen, King

Notable Features

• Chiropractor Recommended

#6 Sealy Posturepedic Natural Origins 16" Plush Euro Top Latex Mattress — Best Pressure Relief for Side Sleepers

Overall score: 9.15 / 10
Price (Queen): $1,020 (typical)  •  Type: Foam Core (No Coils)  •  Firmness: 4.5/10  •  Height: 16.0"
Brand: Sealy  •  Trial: 100-night sleep trial / 90-night comfort guarantee  •  Warranty: 10 Year Warranty
Shipping: FREE Express Delivery (eligible orders) + Canada-wide shipping  •  Returns: Return Policy

Best For

• Side sleepers who want deep, plush pressure relief
• Couples who prioritize motion isolation
• Anyone who likes a taller, more “hotel‑style” build

Considerations

• Tall 16" profile can be heavy and harder to rotate
• Foam edges aren’t as sturdy as coil‑on‑coil designs
• Plush feel isn’t ideal for strict stomach sleepers

Our Verdict

If your top priority is plush, pressure-relieving comfort, the Sealy Natural Origins euro-top stands out. It’s tall, cushy, and designed to cradle shoulders and hips—especially for side sleepers.

Even though it includes latex in the comfort stack, this model leans more into a foam-core “hug” than a springy latex-hybrid feel. That’s a plus for motion isolation, but it’s not as bouncy as coil models.

Choose this if you want a softer, more luxurious feel and you don’t rely heavily on edge support for sleeping space.

Check current price: View Sealy Posturepedic Natural Origins 16" Plush Euro Top Latex Mattress →
Read more: Full specifications of Sealy Posturepedic Natural Origins 16" Plush Euro Top Latex Mattress →

Performance Breakdown (Scores)

Test Notes

• Sinkage depth: 2.80" (feel: deep)
• Bounce height: 2.80"
• Motion transfer: 2.00 / 10 (lower = less partner disturbance; standardized drop-test rating)
• Response time: 2.90s mostly recovered / 5.00s fully recovered
• Edge sitting sinkage: 4.20"
• Off-gassing: 2 days, smell: medium

Specs

• Cover: Organic Cotton Infused with Bamboo
• Quilt: SealyCool Fibres with Silk & Wool
• Comfort layers:
  • 2" OEKO-TEX Certified BioGel Latex
  • 1 1/2" SealySupport™ HD Foam
  • 2" SealySupport™ Gel HD Foam
• Support layers:
  • Targeted ComfortSense Memory Foam
• Support core: HD SealySupport Core, density 1.8 lb/ft³
• Certifications:
  • CertiPUR-US® (low-VOC foam standard)
• Available firmness options: This model is Plush. Other firmness options may be available within the Sealy® Posturepedic® Natural Origins series—check the collection page for current availability.
• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full/Double, Queen, King

Notable Features

• OEKO-TEX Certified

#7 Beautyrest 12.5" Tight Top Extra-firm Mattress — Best for Heavy / Stomach Sleepers

Overall score: 9.00 / 10
Price (Queen): $805 (typical)  •  Type: Innerspring (Pocket Coil)  •  Firmness: 8.5/10  •  Height: 12.5"
Brand: Beautyrest  •  Trial: 100-night sleep trial / 90-night comfort guarantee  •  Warranty: 10 Year Warranty
Shipping: FREE Express Delivery (eligible orders) + Canada-wide shipping  •  Returns: Return Policy

Best For

• Stomach sleepers who need a flatter, firmer surface
• Heavier sleepers looking for extra-firm support
• Couples who want bounce + sturdy support

Considerations

• Extra‑firm can create shoulder/hip pressure for side sleepers
• Tight‑top has less cushioning than a pillow‑top
• Firmer surface can feel “hard” if you’re used to foam hug

Our Verdict

Beautyrest’s extra-firm tight top is built for sleepers who want a flatter, firmer surface with minimal sink—think stomach sleepers and heavier back sleepers.

The cooling surface and gel-infused foams help keep the top from feeling clammy, while the pocket-coil support adds stability and some bounce.

Skip this if you’re a sensitive side sleeper. Extra-firm beds can create pressure at the shoulder and hip without enough surface cushioning.

Check current price: View Beautyrest 12.5" Tight Top Extra-firm Mattress →
Read more: Full specifications of Beautyrest 12.5" Tight Top Extra-firm Mattress →

Performance Breakdown (Scores)

Test Notes

• Sinkage depth: 1.07" (feel: minimal)
• Bounce height: 6.60"
• Motion transfer: 3.80 / 10 (lower = less partner disturbance; standardized drop-test rating)
• Response time: 0.70s mostly recovered / 1.50s fully recovered
• Edge sitting sinkage: 2.80"
• Off-gassing: 1–2 days, smell: low-medium

Specs

• Cover: InfiniCool™ Technology Cooling Sleep Surface
• Quilt: Beautyrest® Antimicrobial Fibre Technology
• Comfort layers:
  • 1/2" Beautyrest® ActiveResponse Memory Foam
  • 1/2" SurfaceTouch™ Gel Memory Foam
• Support layers:
  • 3" Beautyrest® Extra Firm Gel Foam
  • 1/2" Beautyrest® Support Foam
  • 1/2" Beautyrest® Support Foam
• Support core: 875 Pocketed Coil® Technology coils, 875 Pocketed Coil® Technology, gauge 13 3/4
• Certifications:
  • CertiPUR-US® (low-VOC foam standard)
• Available firmness options: This model is Extra Firm. Other firmness options may be available within the Beautyrest® Classic series—check the collection page for current availability.
• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full/Double, Queen, King

Notable Features

• Signature Individualized Support
• Motion Separation

#8 Beautyrest World Class 15.5" Pillow Top Medium-firm Mattress — Best Luxury Pillow-Top Feel

Overall score: 8.85 / 10
Price (Queen): $1,180 (typical)  •  Type: Innerspring (Pocket Coil)  •  Firmness: 6.5/10  •  Height: 15.5"
Brand: Beautyrest  •  Trial: 100-night sleep trial / 90-night comfort guarantee  •  Warranty: 10 Year Warranty
Shipping: FREE Express Delivery (eligible orders) + Canada-wide shipping  •  Returns: Return Policy

Best For

• Shoppers who want a true pillow‑top luxury feel
• Side and combo sleepers who need pressure relief
• Couples who want a cushier top with solid support

Considerations

• Higher price in this list
• Thick pillow‑tops can sleep warmer for some
• Heavier mattress may need rotation help

Our Verdict

The Beautyrest World Class pillow-top is the “treat yourself” pick: thick comfort layers and a plush quilted surface give it a true luxury feel.

It’s especially appealing for side sleepers and combo sleepers who want pressure relief without losing coil support underneath.

The trade-off is price and height. If you love a hotel-style pillow-top and you don’t mind paying more, it’s a great upgrade.

Check current price: View Beautyrest World Class 15.5" Pillow Top Medium-firm Mattress →
Read more: Full specifications of Beautyrest World Class 15.5" Pillow Top Medium-firm Mattress →

Performance Breakdown (Scores)

Test Notes

• Sinkage depth: 1.92" (feel: moderate)
• Bounce height: 5.70"
• Motion transfer: 3.40 / 10 (lower = less partner disturbance; standardized drop-test rating)
• Response time: 1.00s mostly recovered / 1.90s fully recovered
• Edge sitting sinkage: 3.30"
• Off-gassing: 1–2 days, smell: low-medium

Specs

• Cover: InfiniCool™ MAX Technology Cooling Sleep Surface
• Quilt: Beautyrest® Natural Lux Fibre Technology
• Comfort layers:
  • 1" Beautyrest® ActiveResponse Memory Foam
  • 1/2" SurfaceTouch™ Gel Memory Foam
  • 1 1/4" AirFeel™ Foam
• Support layers:
  • 3" Beautyrest® Medium Gel Foam
  • 1" World Class Relief™ HD Foam
  • 1/2" Beautyrest® Support Foam
• Support core: 1000 Pocketed Coil® Technology coils, 1000 Pocketed Coil® Technology, gauge 13 3/4
• Certifications:
  • CertiPUR-US® (low-VOC foam standard)
• Available firmness options: This model is Medium. Other firmness options may be available within the Beautyrest® World Class™ series—check the collection page for current availability.
• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full/Double, Queen, King

Notable Features

• Premier Individualized Support
• Motion Separation

#9 Serta Perfect Sleeper Premium 15" Firm Pillow Top Mattress — Best Balanced Firm Pillow-Top

Overall score: 8.70 / 10
Price (Queen): $901 (typical)  •  Type: Innerspring (Pocket Coil)  •  Firmness: 7.5/10  •  Height: 15.0"
Brand: Serta  •  Trial: 100-night sleep trial / 90-night comfort guarantee  •  Warranty: 10 Year Warranty
Shipping: FREE Express Delivery (eligible orders) + Canada-wide shipping  •  Returns: Return Policy

Best For

• Back sleepers who want firm support with a pillow‑top touch
• Couples who like a traditional coil feel
• Anyone who wants a classic “firm but not hard” surface

Considerations

• Pillow‑top feel can soften over time (normal for plush comfort layers)
• Not as cool as latex-heavy or PCM-heavy builds
• 15" height may require deep-pocket sheets

Our Verdict

Serta’s Perfect Sleeper Premium firm pillow-top is a classic crowd-pleaser: supportive, slightly cushioned on top, and built on a pocketed coil system.

It’s a strong match for back sleepers who want firmness without feeling like they’re sleeping on a board, and it performs well for most couples.

If you want a traditional mattress feel with modern cooling and comfort foams, this is a safe pick.

Check current price: View Serta Perfect Sleeper Premium 15" Firm Pillow Top Mattress →
Read more: Full specifications of Serta Perfect Sleeper Premium 15" Firm Pillow Top Mattress →

Performance Breakdown (Scores)

Test Notes

• Sinkage depth: 1.67" (feel: moderate)
• Bounce height: 5.90"
• Motion transfer: 3.40 / 10 (lower = less partner disturbance; standardized drop-test rating)
• Response time: 0.85s mostly recovered / 1.70s fully recovered
• Edge sitting sinkage: 3.05"
• Off-gassing: 1–2 days, smell: low-medium

Specs

• Cover: Not listed
• Quilt: CoolFeel Fabric™ with Antimicrobial Mattress Protection* + Serta® Antimicrobial Fibre
• Comfort layers:
  • 1” PillowSoft® Foam
  • 1/2” Serta® Support Foam
  • 1” Cool Twist® Gel Memory Foam
• Support layers:
  • 3” Serta® Support Foam
  • 1” PillowSoft® Foam
  • 1/2” Serta® Balanced Support Pad
• Support core: 544-1292 coils, 1000 Series 3-Zoned Coil System, gauge 16/15.5/16
• Certifications:
  • CertiPUR-US® (low-VOC foam standard)
• Available firmness options: This model is Firm. Other firmness options may be available within the Serta® Perfect Sleeper® series—check the collection page for current availability.
• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full/Double, Queen, King

Notable Features

• The Perfect Sleeper®, in partnership with the National Sleep Foundation, helps solve the most common sleep problems: Tossing/turning, sleeping too hot or too cold, partner disturbance and more.

#10 Sealy Cocoon 10" Firm Memory Foam Mattress — Best Memory Foam in a Box

Overall score: 8.55 / 10
Price (Queen): $829 (typical)  •  Type: Memory Foam  •  Firmness: 7.5/10  •  Height: 10.0"
Brand: Sealy  •  Trial: 100-night sleep trial / 90-night comfort guarantee  •  Warranty: 10 Year Warranty
Shipping: FREE Express Delivery (eligible orders) + Canada-wide shipping  •  Returns: Return Policy

Best For

• Couples who need strong motion isolation
• Guest rooms / easy delivery setups
• Back sleepers who prefer a firm, supportive foam feel

Considerations

• Edge support is weaker than most coil models
• Lower bounce (not ideal if you prioritize responsiveness/sex score)
• Foam can sleep warmer—pair with breathable bedding if you run hot

Our Verdict

Sealy Cocoon is the simplest way to get premium-brand memory foam convenience: a supportive all-foam feel, easy setup, and excellent motion isolation.

It’s best for back sleepers or couples who want less partner disturbance. The firm feel also means you won’t sink as deeply as you would on a plush memory foam bed.

If you need strong edges or a bouncier surface, choose a hybrid instead. But for a streamlined foam option, Cocoon is a solid mid-level premium pick.

Check current price: View Sealy Cocoon 10" Firm Memory Foam Mattress →
Read more: Full specifications of Sealy Cocoon 10" Firm Memory Foam Mattress →

Performance Breakdown (Scores)

Test Notes

• Sinkage depth: 1.73" (feel: moderate)
• Bounce height: 2.80"
• Motion transfer: 1.80 / 10 (lower = less partner disturbance; standardized drop-test rating)
• Response time: 2.45s mostly recovered / 4.40s fully recovered
• Edge sitting sinkage: 3.45"
• Off-gassing: 3 days, smell: medium

Specs

• Cover: Not listed
• Quilt: Premium Stretch-Knit Fabric
• Comfort layers:
  • 2″ Perfect Fit Memory Foam
• Support layers:
  • 2″ Reinforced Essential Support Foam Firm
• Support core: Flexible Essential Support Foam, density 1.8 lb/ft³
• Certifications:
  • CertiPUR-US® (low-VOC foam standard)
• Available firmness options: This model is Firm. Other firmness options may be available within the Sealy® Cocoon™ series—check the collection page for current availability.
• Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full/Double, Queen, King

Notable Features

• Compressed and Rolled for Easy Shipping & Handling

Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose the Best Premium Mattress

1) Pick your firmness based on sleep position

• Side sleepers: typically 4–6.5/10 (look for plusher euro-top or pillow-top comfort).
• Back sleepers: typically 6–8/10 (medium-firm to firm support keeps the spine aligned).
• Stomach sleepers: typically 7–9/10 (firmer helps prevent hip sink).
• Combo sleepers: prioritize responsiveness—latex and hybrid builds make switching positions easier.

Browse by feel: Firm mattresses or Extra-firm mattresses.

2) Cooling: what actually helps

For hot sleepers, “cooling” works best when it’s built into the structure—not just a marketing label. Look for:

• Breathable covers (cooling yarns, moisture-wicking fibres)
• Open, ventilated support cores (pocket coils allow airflow)
• Natural temperature regulators (latex, wool)
• Phase-change materials (PCM) or gel-infused foams (can help reduce initial heat buildup)

See more options: Cooling mattresses.

3) Pressure relief vs. ease of movement

Plush comfort layers (especially memory foam) can relieve pressure, but too much sink can make moving harder. If you want pressure relief and mobility, latex hybrids often hit the sweet spot.

Explore constructions: Memory foam mattresses, Hybrid mattresses, and Latex mattresses.

4) Couples: motion + edge support

If you share a bed, two factors matter most: motion isolation (so you don’t feel every toss and turn) and edge support (so you can use the full surface without roll-off).

• For motion isolation, foam and foam-core builds usually win. See: Low motion transfer mattresses.
• For edge support, look for reinforced perimeters and stronger coil systems. See: Edge support mattresses.

More couple-friendly options: Mattresses for couples.

5) Policies that matter (and why they affect value)

• Shipping: Check delivery timing and whether you qualify for free delivery. See: FREE Express Delivery and Canada-wide shipping.
• Trial/comfort guarantee: National Mattress lists both a 100-night sleep trial and a 90-night comfort guarantee on different pages—always confirm which applies to your purchase.
• Returns: Read the fine print before you buy. See: Return Policy.
• Certifications: For foam beds, look for CertiPUR-US®. For organic/latex builds, certifications like OEKO‑TEX® and GOLS can be helpful.

If you’re unsure where to start, the two simplest filters are Premium mattresses and Mattresses for back pain.

FAQs

What firmness is best for a premium (mid-level) mattress?

For most sleepers, a true medium-firm feel (around 6–7/10) is the safest choice because it balances pressure relief and support. If you’re mostly a side sleeper, go slightly softer (around 4–6/10). If you’re a back or stomach sleeper, a firmer feel (around 7–9/10) usually helps keep your hips from sinking.

Are premium mattresses good for back pain?

They can be—if the mattress matches your body type and sleep position. Back-pain shoppers usually do best with a medium-firm to firm feel and strong edge/support systems. In this list, firmer euro-top and hybrid builds tend to provide the most “lift” and spinal alignment.

How long do premium mattresses last?

Most well-built premium mattresses last about 7–10 years, depending on materials, body weight, and care (using a supportive base and rotating when recommended). Latex and higher-density foams often hold up longer than lower-density comfort foams.

Do these mattresses contain fiberglass?

Fiberglass policies vary by brand and model. We did not see fiberglass listed in the product specs provided for this roundup, but we recommend confirming on the product page and with the manufacturer if it’s a concern. Natural fibre builds (like wool/latex) are often a safer bet for shoppers trying to avoid fiberglass.

Which mattress is best for hot sleepers?

If overheating is your #1 issue, start with the Evergreen organic latex pick (#1) or the Springwall Chiropractic cooling-focused euro-top (#2). Latex, breathable fibres, coils, and phase-change style cooling materials usually outperform traditional all-foam beds for temperature control.

Bottom Line

If you want the safest all-around choice, get Evergreen 12" Tight-top Medium-firm Organic Latex Mattress for its cool-sleeping latex build, fast response, and strong value in the premium tier.

If you’re on a tighter budget but still want a premium feel, start with Sealy Posturepedic 800 Series 13" Medium Firm Euro Top Mattress (our value pick).

If you sleep hot, choose Springwall Chiropractic 14" Firm Euro Top Mattress for its cooling-focused materials and supportive euro-top design.

Next step: Compare today’s promotions across the full premium category here: Shop Premium Mattresses →