Our Factory Clearance Sale is on now!

Plush Extra Firm Medium Sealy® Essentials Mattress Selector

Plush mattresses are the softest comfort level we carry — built with thick pillow-top and euro-top comfort layers (plus plush memory foam and hybrid options) that cradle your shoulders and hips for a soft, sink-in feel. Plush is the top choice for side sleepers and lighter-weight sleepers who need extra cushioning at the pressure points; back and stomach sleepers, or anyone who wants firmer support, may prefer our medium or firm options. Shop plush models from Sealy, Serta, Beautyrest, Stearns & Foster, iComfort and Tempur-Pedic in memory foam, hybrid and pocket-coil builds — with free delivery across Canada. • Feel: plush is the softest of our four comfort levels (plush, medium, firm, extra firm) • Best for: side sleepers and lighter-weight sleepers — cushions shoulders and hips • Consider firmer if: you sleep on your back or stomach, are heavier, or want more support • Plush constructions: pillow-top, euro-top, plush memory foam and hybrid • Builds: memory foam, hybrid and pocket-coil • Brands: Sealy, Serta, Beautyrest, Stearns & Foster, iComfort & Tempur-Pedic • Prices: from $224 to premium
Extra firm mattresses are the firmest, most supportive feel we carry — a hard, no-sink surface that holds your body on top of the mattress rather than letting it settle in. They're built for stomach sleepers, heavier-weight sleepers and anyone who finds a standard firm mattress still too soft, delivering maximum support and spinal alignment. Most use a tight-top or high-density foam construction (including orthopedic Chirofoam), with budget-friendly options that keep extra-firm support affordable. Shop Beautyrest, Serta, Chirofoam, Springwall and our own NM line — from $152, with free delivery across Canada. • Feel: extra firm is the firmest of our four comfort levels — a hard, no-sink surface • Best for: stomach sleepers, heavier-weight sleepers, and anyone who wants maximum support • Choose this over firm if a standard firm mattress still feels too soft • Consider firm or medium if you sleep on your side or want any cushioning • Constructions: tight-top and high-density foam (including orthopedic Chirofoam) • Brands: Beautyrest, Serta, Chirofoam, Springwall & NM • Prices: from $152 — an affordable, value-focused selection
Medium-firmness mattresses — often called medium-firm — sit right between plush and firm, which is why they're the most popular and versatile feel we carry. You get enough cushioning to relieve pressure with enough support to keep your spine aligned, making medium a safe choice for back sleepers, combination sleepers who change positions through the night, and couples who need a compromise between two preferences. Shop medium models from Sealy, Serta, Beautyrest, Stearns & Foster, iComfort and Tempur-Pedic across memory foam, hybrid, euro-top, pillow-top and tight-top builds — with free delivery across Canada. • Feel: medium sits between plush and firm — balanced and the most versatile of our four comfort levels • Also called "medium-firm" — the middle of the firmness scale • Best for: back sleepers, combination sleepers, couples, and most body types • Consider plush if you sleep on your side; firm if you sleep on your stomach or want more support • Constructions: euro-top, tight-top, pillow-top, memory foam and hybrid • Brands: Sealy, Serta, Beautyrest, Stearns & Foster, iComfort, Tempur-Pedic, Springwall & NM • Prices: from $171 to premium
Sealy® Essentials mattresses provide reliable comfort and support at a budget-friendly price. This collection offers the perfect balance of innerspring support and cooling foam comfort, delivering Sealy quality to Canadians at great value.
Plush Extra Firm Medium Sealy® Essentials Mattress Selector
Loading recommendations...

Items

Items

  • Sealy Essentials 8-inch medium-firm tight-top foam mattress, quilted blue-grey top, white sides, navy piping Sealy Essentials Mattress Logo
    • CleanProtect™ Fabric
    • SealyLoft™ Quilt with Moisture Wicking Fibres
    • CertiPUR-US™ SealySupport™ HD Foam
    • CertiPUR-US™ SealySupport™ HD Core
    • SealySupport™ HD Foam
    Single/Twin $298
    Twin XL In stock for fast delivery $382
    Double/Full In stock for fast delivery $388
    Queen $420
    Compare at $999
    King $591
    Online availability icon In-Stock Only 5 left!
    In-Store availability icon On Display:
    Free delivery availability icon Free delivery to M5H 2N1 as soon as Tomorrow, Sep 8
    Pickup available icon Only Pickup available to
    M5H 2N1
  • Sealy Essentials 11-inch medium-firm tight-top mattress, blue-speckled flat top, white pinstriped sides Sealy Essentials Mattress Logo
    • CleanProtect™ Fabric
    • SealyLoft™ Quilt with Moisture Wicking Fibres
    • CertiPUR-US™ SealySupport™ HD Foam
    • Posture Touch® Pocket Coils
    • EssentialEdge™ Coil Support
    Single/Twin In stock for fast delivery $409
    Twin XL In stock for fast delivery $423
    Double/Full $462
    Queen $505
    Compare at $1,199
    King $675
    Online availability icon In-Stock Only 3 left!
    In-Store availability icon On Display:
    Free delivery availability icon Free delivery to M5H 2N1 as soon as Tomorrow, Sep 8
    Pickup available icon Only Pickup available to
    M5H 2N1
  • Sealy Essentials 10.5-inch medium-firm euro-top foam mattress, blue-speckled top, white sides on black base Sealy Essentials Mattress Logo
    • CleanProtect™ Fabric
    • SealyLoft™ Quilt with Moisture Wicking Fibres
    • CertiPUR-US™ SealySupport™ HD Foam
    • CertiPUR-US™ SealySupport™ HD Core
    • SealySupport™ HD Foam
    Single/Twin $432
    Twin XL In stock for fast delivery $478
    Double/Full $486
    Queen $505
    Compare at $1,199
    King $655
    Online availability icon In-Stock Only 3 left!
    In-Store availability icon On Display:
    Free delivery availability icon Free delivery to M5H 2N1 as soon as Tomorrow, Sep 8
    Pickup available icon Only Pickup available to
    M5H 2N1

3 Items

How the Mattress Selector Works

The selector asks the questions a good salesperson asks in the first two minutes — who the bed is for, your sleep position, your body type, where you ache, how warm you sleep, the feel you prefer, whether you want a pillow top, and (optionally) your budget — then uses your answers to narrow the range down to a shortlist. It draws on the same mattresses you can browse by hand, including Beautyrest, Serta, Sealy, Springwall, Tempur-Pedic and Stearns & Foster.

Answer the feel question honestly rather than aspirationally — if you’ve slept well on firm beds your whole life, say firm. Side sleepers generally need more give at the shoulder and hip, back and stomach sleepers want less sink so the spine stays neutral, and body weight changes how deeply any mattress compresses — which is why two people can lie on the same bed and honestly call it soft and firm. Whatever the selector suggests is a starting point, not a verdict: you can lie on the result at any of our seven Ontario showrooms, and every mattress it recommends carries the 365-night sleep trial.

A Filter, Not an Oracle

It narrows the full mattress range to a shortlist using what you tell it about how you sleep — treat the result as a starting point for browsing, not a verdict.

Matched to How You Sleep

Sleep position drives support needs: side sleepers generally need more give at the shoulder and hip, while back and stomach sleepers usually do better with less sink.

Protected by the 365-Night Trial

No form can know how a bed feels after three weeks — the 365-night sleep trial covers that part. Every mattress it recommends carries the trial, clearance and discontinued stock excepted — that’s sold as-is.

No Commission, No Steering

Our sleep experts aren’t paid commission — they earn the same whichever mattress you pick, and the same whether you buy today or not.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Mattress Selector

What does the mattress selector ask?
Who the bed is for, your sleep position, your body type, where you ache, how warm you sleep, the feel you prefer, whether you want a pillow top, and your budget. Budget is optional — leave it blank and you’ll still see a range of matches.
Is the mattress quiz accurate?
It’s accurate about what it can measure and silent about the rest. It narrows the field using what you told it about position, body type and feel — but it can’t tell you which of three well-matched mattresses you’ll personally love. Only lying on them can, which is what our showrooms and the 365-night sleep trial are for.
Will it push me toward expensive mattresses?
Nobody here earns more for selling you a dearer bed — our staff aren’t paid commission. What’s true is that better-built mattresses tend to cost more, so a shortlist weighted toward quality can skew upward. If that happens, set a budget and run it again, or sort the results by price and work from the other end.
Do I have to use the selector to shop?
No. If you already know what you want, browse all mattresses directly and filter by feel — plush to extra firm — by type like memory foam or hybrid, or by size. The selector exists for the much more common case of not knowing where to start.
Can I try my recommendation in person?
Yes — find your nearest of our seven Ontario showrooms and lie on your shortlist. Floor models are shared across the network: if a style is on display at any one store, its sizes are available to order company-wide, stock permitting.
What if the recommendation turns out to be wrong?
Then it’s wrong, and the 365-night sleep trial is how you fix it. A mattress needs a few weeks to break in and your body needs a few weeks to adjust — any trial short enough to expire before that has happened isn’t much of a trial.

Prefer to Browse — or Talk to a Person?

The selector is a shortcut, not a requirement. Browse the full range at your own pace, or visit a showroom and tell a non-commissioned sleep expert how you sleep — they do the same narrowing by hand, with better follow-up questions than any form can ask.

Loading recommendations...